Our Products

We make everything ourselves using only milk from our A2A2, grass-fed cows.

Everything is minimally processed and made with as few ingredients as possible.

The Lineup

Tangy Kefir

Kefir is a tangy, creamy, cultured milk drink similar to yogurt. It’s full of probiotics. Enjoy as-is, or use it as the base for smoothies. It’s an excellent substitute for buttermilk in recipes like pancakes or biscuits.

Plain (24oz)
Nutritional info

Vanilla (24oz)
Nutritional info

Blueberry and Honey (32oz)
Nutritional info

Honey (24oz)
Nutritional info

Strawberry (32oz)
Nutritional info

Peach and Honey (32oz)
Nutritional info

Creamy Yogurt

The cream top on our grass fed yogurt is pure heaven. Enjoy it for breakfast or a snack with cereal or granola. Use it to create dips like tzatziki, in place of sour cream on tacos, or to cut the heat in spicy dishes. 

Plain (32oz)
Nutritional info

Vanilla (32oz)
Nutritional info

Maple (32oz)
Nutritional info

Cultured Butter

Cultured butter is thicker, richer, and more flavorful than regular butter. Our grass-fed butter is velvety and delicious. Use it to make the best toast you’ve ever had, or to enhance all kinds of dishes.

Cultured Butter (9oz)
Nutritional info

What Dairy Lovers Are Saying

"This is really delicious stuff. My toddler especially loves the kefir!"

— Zoe S.

"My husband and I enjoy this yummy yogurt and butter and appreciate how it’s made."

— Jackie T.

"Now that I’ve had cultured butter, I’ll never go back to the stuff in the grocery store."

— Mark R.

Where to Find Elmer & Sarah’s